Someone emails you. Within a second they get an email back: you got their message, you reply within 48 business hours, here are your office hours. Two days later they answer your actual reply and get the same email again. They send a quick “thanks!” and get it a third time.
No client feels taken care of by that third one. Honestly, they didn’t feel taken care of by the first one either.
I get why people set these up. Somewhere along the way, “set expectations” turned into “send an automated message every time someone contacts you.” An inbox autoresponder is the easiest automation there is, so it’s often the first one a business owner turns on. It feels like a system, but the person on the other end learns nothing they couldn’t have guessed.
Here’s the test I use for any automated email: does it give the person something they asked for, or tell them something they don’t already know? A magic link passes. When someone logs into Dubsado Alchemy, the email with the login link IS the thing they came for. The confirmation after someone joins my newsletter tells them it worked and what’s coming. People open emails like that: IBM’s email benchmark put the average open rate for transactional emails at 44.7%, about double the 22.6% for marketing emails.
An autoresponder on your regular inbox fails both halves of that test. Everyone already assumes you aren’t sitting there waiting for their email. If you use Gmail’s built-in vacation responder, Google sends it to each person once, and again only if they write after four days. The autoresponders I keep getting don’t have that limit, so clients, contractors and vendors get them on every reply, and they become the email everyone deletes without opening.
They also tell people you’ll be slower than they hoped. In Jeff Toister’s 2018 survey of more than 1,200 consumers, the most common expected reply time from a business was one day, picked by 43%. An auto-reply promising 48 business hours tells most of those people, in writing, that you’ll miss that.
Needing one is a systems problem
If your inbox is busy enough that you feel you need an autoresponder, your systems aren’t doing their job. When your admin is automated, most of what used to land in your inbox never needs you. Inquiries go through a lead capture form that starts a workflow, so the person gets your scheduler link and pricing guide right away. Contracts, invoices and payment reminders go out on their own, and clients know where to find answers before they think to email you. The emails left in your inbox are the ones that actually need you, and there are few enough of them that you can just answer them.
An autoresponder puts a polite note on top of the backlog, while fixing your systems shrinks the backlog itself.
If you want people to know your response times, put them where people look before they write: your contact page, your email signature, the welcome packet you send new clients. Tell clients once, at onboarding, how and when you answer email. A vacation responder is fine too, because it tells people something they don’t know and it turns off when you get back.
So turn it off. If your response time is reasonable, your clients never needed the warning, and if it isn’t, an autoresponder won’t fix that.